jstarne1
USA
Asked
— Edited
Hi , I have been shopping for sensors and reading about 2d mapping using.radar.extra.and I also read on some random sites that a good electronic compass is a good addition to get your robot correct orientation if it deviated from a original path avoiding a object or if the little guy.just.just drive perfectly straight. are these compass modules useful.to.tell your.robot which.direction to.go.or slightly correct.itself? I apologize for all the random periods because I just bought a new Samsung galaxy note and IM still getting use to it. The auto correct is changing words to what it thinks I should have said I guess lol
This one is under 20 dollars and has self calibration, user defined zero.position. Can.some.one look at this and tell.me if ezb can read the signal in a useful way?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Arduino-Electric-Digital-Compass-Sensor-transducer-Module-Compatible-Robot-New-/221089503297?pt=BI_Electrical_Equipment_Tools&hash=item3379f61841
I like the LEDs around the edge showing the direction. Its hard to say if its straightforward to intergrate to the EZB it doesn't say anywhere that I can find that its I2C probably isn't.
The Sure Electronics DC-SS503V100 already added by DJ to EZB is a better bet but difficult to obtain now as it looks like discontinued stock (in the UK in any case)
The device I like is SparkFun Compass Module - HMC6352 Product Code: SEN-07915 which has I2C and all the documentation perhaps someone on here has already added it to EZB or has another opinion
Found this Arduino code for it. (Might point us in the right direction) ;-)
Looks like it is serial, so it should work with the EZ-B if configured correctly.
Here's an Ebay link for the one DJ uses, orded mine a few weeks ago.
the link
Thanks budeI0 looks like its from China let us know when you get it please
budel0 go! I was not able to find it on ebay and here it is! I'm also waiting to see if it works well, I guess that somehow affect the magnetic fields of the speakers if they are located near the sensor. I have also read in the tutorial DJ i2c connection cables must be short.
I find it ironic it comes from "sure" electronics. Lol It took me a few minutes but I found the English version so I could read.it. 15 dollars is not a bad price.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Dual-axis-Magnetic-Sensor-Module-UART-I-2-c-Interface-/230643656408?pt=UK_BOI_Industrial_Automation_Control_ET&hash=item35b36ee6d8
So I must use code there's no ARC option for a I've compass?
Josh,
I bought the cheap sure compass. ARC has a support for it. it draws a compass on the screen and shows you what direction you are headed in. It works great. And, if it doesn't you have a place to calibrate it. this is all automatically built into EZB. But, I believe, you MUST get the I2C version of the SURE compass. D.J. would know whether a digital or analog version would work. But, this one works Great. He even has a video on it.
Hope that this helped,
Mel
Also, you must keep your wires as short as you can.
And, it is the same compass from SURE that you have in the LINK above.
And there are EZ-Script commands for the compass
Ok I'll risk an order to China. Its the lead time and possible local import taxes that shouldn't be applied in this case as the value is too low that normally bothers me so fingers crossed
Anyone tried ferrite beads on the signal wires?
I ordered one as well. No issues with stuff coming from China.
Now on order
i got mine in from SHURE ELECTRONICS and bought other stuff from them too,they seem to be pretyy good,better then others selling SRF04 sensors with i got a few bad ones from but if looking for a much better one with higher accuracy look at CMPS03 OR THE NEW CMPS09 it may last longer and has much higher accuracy ,but with all better sensors more you pay ,better it is old saying always go ,"you get what you paid for " i have the CMPS03 and its working a lot better,but at $50 to $35 each,i got mine ,one for $35 and another for $48 it uses I2C commands,most likely others like to save money,so the one from SHURE ELECTRONIC should work ok,i made a connection board for mine and looking to hook it up to my EZB robot
BUT becarefull where you place it,needs to stay away from magnetic fields,like servo's,motors,hard drives and dc fans or you will not get a correct reading,mostly 6 inches away or more one reaon it hard to place in robots,CHECK the data sheet it will tell you this
also MEL is right,i forgot about keeping the wire short on EZB on other processors doesnt matter,so need to run tests and find out why i think its impedance of the I2C output
don't forget, D.J. has a video on it.
Mel
Hi all, great insight on having a compass but are they accurate enough to navigate with ?
Bob is basically a metal cage full of wires which to me seems a compass nightmare. Short wires ? have it situated away from metal ? Seriously - can they help or are they more a hindrance ?
JOSH the compass you posted a photo of is serial connection, it needs transmit and received transmit is need on most compass to calibrate it and other setups,received is to get the compass reading,a nd EZB only has a one wire rs232 serial ,i think transmit so the olny one that will work are ones with true 12C connection i wish DJ wound add a received command ,good for getting info on roomba sensors and serial communication to other sensors
HAZBOT wires are not the problem as metal too,problem is magnetic fields,compass picks up magnetic fields,so anything thats a magnet ,motors,servo's fans and hard drives will give a wrong reading most data sheets on compass will tell you how much to set them apart of them,mostly 6 inches,compass are fairly accurate ,depend on the company who makes them and calibrates them
here is info from a company that makes the best one Q. Is the Compass affected by Motors, Magnets, Ferrous objects etc? A. Yes. Anything that affects the local magnetic field will affect the Compass module. Motors in particular contain strong magnets. The only solution is to mount the compass as far away from magnetic/ferrous objects as is practicable
here is info on compass on another post i reply too should not need shielded cables on the compass on a robot ,i have it 6 inches away using a pic processor and normal wires,I2C buss you can run long wires thats whats good about it can post the photo of it should be able to run long wires on I2C buss,so 2 problems it may have one is the pull up resistors on the 2 lines or a cheap compass having a week signal
So, I finaly hooked the compass up with my EZ-b. It seems to be working, but after 5 seconds I lose connection and ARC sort of stops working...
Any ideas on whats happening?
might be a reset problem,from noise,did you restart it again in a few weeks mmaybe more looking to do some testing on why the wires need to be short on only SURE compass its very strange,you get long run wire from I2C buss,can post my seeker robot design that i have a I2C compass about 2 feet away from the control board and working fine but i am using CMPS-03,also DAVES SHINSEL SEEKER robot has it too and there where i made mine from with some changes SO thinking the signal is very week form a china made compass or the pull up resistors and some how noises are causing a reset on EZB
also BRUDEL0 do you have a O-SCOPE,best tool for checking noise in the system
Talking to brother who knows about this sort of thing the edges produced by the MCU (or EZ-B in this case) can be too fast for the I2C device so if you put a 100 ohm resistor in the 2 signal lines in series with them. This will take the edge off so to speak as it acts like a small low pass filter with the capacitance of the input stage of the I2C device.
It may not solve the problem of course and I can't try it as my compass module hasn't arrived yet. But its a known solution to intergrating I2C devices with an MCU controller
they may work too,i seen that on another forum but it will also divide the voltage down,since there is a pull up of 10 k and in series adding 100 ohm thats a voltage divider the EZB uses near the same processor thats on my SEEKER robot that uses a CMPS03 that does have that problem at all and using it at 24 inches away from the board
i think on BUDEL0 case is different,seem a noise problem ,not a compass problem ,since others have it working BUDEL0 he is a try ,remove compass and see if you are having same problem ,if you still do ,then not the compass, ,can be noise on the lins (hard to find without a scope) or drawaing to much current from other stuff or on the digital or I2C lines what do you have hook up and where
@robotmaker
No I don't have a scope.
My robot works fine when I don't have the compass connected. When I connect the compass while its connected to my pc it stops working again...
I have connected to my EZ-B:
I think I covered it all.
@winstn60 I will try it. I hope it works, because I'm working on something special for navigation ^^.
ok,so it is the compass.first do you have pull up resistors on each line,very important second adding that 100ohms might help like winstn60 said
@budeI0
Sounds interesting keep us posted hope you get the compass working ))
@winstn60 No succes with the 100 ohm resistors...
Any other ideas?
what pull up resestor do you have on each line,should be 10 k.it seems if you dont have any when the signal or data line with stay low.its only needed if using one if more are hook up to I2C port still only need the 2 10 k resistors,one is SCL other is CLK ,then you have GND and V+ make shore all the wire are connected correctly
sorry another edit here is info on the resistors needed The value of the resistors is not critical. I have seen anything from 1k8 (1800 ohms) to 47k (47000 ohms) used. 1k8, 4k7 and 10k are common values, but anything in this range should work OK. I recommend 1k8 as this gives you the best performance. If the resistors are missing, the SCL and SDA lines will always be low - nearly 0 volts - and the I2C bus will not work
WINSTN60 you sad this The device I like is SparkFun Compass Module - HMC6352 Product Code: SEN-07915 which has I2C and all the documentation perhaps someone on here has already added it to EZB or has another opinion
a lot better choice thats used in robotics a lot is CMPS10 HIGHER ACCURACY .1 DEGREE compare to SPARKFUN compass at .5 degree and at the same cost $34.95 from dfrobots both have I2C interface and replaced the very popular CMPS03 compass used in robotics alot ,whats added is tilt compensated CMPS10 COMPASS
i have CMPS03 compass and one from china ,HOPE SOON to do some testing and make a I2C code for it,should work with the CMPS10 witch i am going to have on order too
JOSH that compass from SHURE electronics that DJ is using has very bad accuracy Accuracy1 2 to 5 deg compare to .5 deg on sparkfun and .1 deg on CMPS10 ITS LITTLE MORE PRICE FOR THEM but worth the extra cost for better navigation
here is some great info on using the I2C buss i found awhile back I2C BUSS tutorial
Hi budeI0
Thats frustrating hopefully I will have the same compass module as you delivered in a few days and I do have a scope. Also worth trying pull up resistors as robotmaker states
Read this from DJ in I2C help on this site
" i2c Wire Length and Pull Up Resistors
If you modify or extend the wire on the i2c device, keep the individual wires (GND, +5, SDA, SCL) from being twisted together. You will notice i2c cables are flat, much like an older IDE Hard Drive Cable. Building your own i2c extension cable is not easy with regular wire. You can try different pull-up resistors, which decreases the sensitivity of your communication, but also removes noise. Ideally you should be using a special i2c cable.
Pull-Up resistors are connected between +5 to SDA and +5 to SCL. They are required for i2c device communication. The EZ-B has 2 pull-up resistors on board for the i2c. If a long thick wire is used (specifically if twisted), you may need to add 2 more resistors. The pull-ups range from 1k ohm to 10k ohm. You may need to expirement with a variety of resistors to find your ideal value"
@BUDEI0 i would read the IC2 page i put a link too it tell you all info on using I2C buss ,from clock pluses to how to write a code for it
another update on compass boards testing,i got a free gauss meter (magnetic field meter) from work ,since i am in the design and test lab at work where i build high precision test equipment for the tester we make so will be able to do tests on the magnetic compasses fairly soon,as soon as i get the CMPS10 from china,can test all 3 of them,accuracy i cant check but specs tell you the accuracy mostly only checking how far from magnetic fields it needs to be away and I2C distance problem
Hey RobotMaker,
I enjoy your well thought out posts.
Have you received your compass yet? When you do please post your i2c code here on your procedure for reading from it. I'm trying to read the I2C port of an IMU 6050 but I'm not understanding the EZ script code for that yet. The specs say it's address is 0x69 or 0x68 but with some sample code from someone reading another device would enable me to change it to this device.
I am using 4.7K pull up resisters and under 3 inch untwisted wires with the EZ-B 3.3 volts.
Here's one thing I've tried but not sure how far off I am: I2CStart() I2CRestart()
I2CPoll() I2CWrite( 0x68, 0, 1)
I2CRead( auto,11)
I2CStop()
The output of my script is: Start I2C Poll Response: False I2C Response: 255 255 255 255 255 255 255 255 255 255 255 Done
Thanks,
Bill
its on backorder,and i may not get before i leave on a 3 week vacation trip leaving in 2 weeks
Finally got my compass sort of working, well it doesn't give of it's standard direction of 45 degrees it used to give of. It actually changes, its giving of the actual direction its facing, but it only works for a very short time. After that it sort of crashes ARC... It stays stuck in "connected" while the LED on the EZ-b is pulsating, like it's not connected. So I think it's browning out my EZ-b... I'll try powering it from an alternative powersource.
I'm using 2k resistors. And made a board for it.
Hi all, does anyone have a update to this thread? I have my sure electronics compass working, but it is less then I hoped it would be. North never seems to be quite right and west and east will sometimes switch. I'm guessing interference is the problem, but I have also read in other post that I can try either a pull up resistor to ground or +5 volts. My robot is fairly compacts so I'm hoping to find something that will be a little less sensitive to the interference and have better accuracy. @Robotmaker did you have any luck with your test on the other 3 compass modules?
Try the pull-up resistors, I've read in other topics that some sensors which were not working at all start working when pull-ups are installed.
Compass modules will be susceptible to interference so relocating it may be an idea.
@RobotMaker no longer frequents the forum. @MovieMaker and a few others are in contact with him still I believe, perhaps they could ask?
Thanks for the update Rich, I will give the resistors a shot. I've been out of the scene for over a year as well. The new V4 board and EZ-bit robots got my attention back though. My little guy is starting to get interested in robots too so that helps